Casey Anthony, acquitted in 2011 of murdering her two-year-old daughter, Caylee, has returned to the public eye with a March 1, 2025, video that’s racked up over 2 million views, announcing her new role as a “legal advocate” on Substack—a platform where writers monetize content through subscriptions starting at $10 a month or offer free “occasional public posts.” Her reintroduction, 16 years after Caylee’s death, has ignited a firestorm online, with X users reviving old allegations—like her 30-day delay in reporting Caylee missing, chloroform searches, and DNA evidence in her trunk—questioning how she escaped conviction.
Meanwhile, calls to “Boycott Substack” and comments like “She should go back in hiding” reflect a public unwilling to forgive or forget, some even twisting her LGBTQ+ advocacy claims into political fodder.
Her acquittal, delivered on July 5, 2011, by a 12-person jury, stunned a courtroom expecting a harsh sentence for “America’s most hated woman,” convicting her only of lying to police and freeing her two weeks later—an outcome one juror later justified to People as a lack of evidence, despite personal distaste.
Now, Anthony’s Substack venture, promising legal resources and a direct email, is met with visceral rejection—“I’d puke,” one viewer wrote—underscoring a divide between her self-styled redemption and an internet still raw with suspicion.
Is this a genuine fresh start or a cash grab banking on infamy?
The debate rages on.